How to Handle "We're Already Working with Someone Else" in Insurance & Risk Management Sales
Expert framework for overcoming the "We're Already Working with Someone Else" objection in Insurance sales. Proven 3-step method with industry-specific examples.
ScriptFly AI Team
Expert Sales Trainers
How to Handle "We're Already Working with Someone Else" in Insurance & Risk Management Sales
Every insurance sales rep knows that sinking feeling when a promising prospect drops the ultimate conversation stopper: "We're already working with someone else." It's the objection that can turn a hot lead ice-cold in seconds, crushing your pipeline and your confidence in one swift blow.
Why Insurance Prospects Say "We're Already Working with Someone Else"
In the world of insurance and risk management, loyalty runs deep. Prospects aren't just buying a policy; they're investing in a relationship of trust that protects their most valuable assets. This isn't just a transaction – it's a complex dance of perceived security and long-standing connections.
The Real Reasons Behind This Objection:
- Comfort with the current relationship
- Fear of disrupting existing insurance coverage
- Perception that switching is more complicated than staying
- Misguided belief that all insurance providers are essentially the same
The Wrong Way to Respond (That Most Reps Do)
Most sales reps crumble when they hear this objection. They become defensive, desperate, or worse – completely shut down.
Don't:
- ❌ Argue or badmouth their current provider
- ❌ Immediately launch into a features dump
- ❌ Apologize or sound defeated
- ❌ Try to steamroll through the objection
The 3-Step Framework That Actually Works
Step 1: Acknowledge Without Agreeing
The key is to show respect while creating just enough doubt about their current arrangement.Example Response:
"I completely understand your loyalty to your current insurance partner. Many of our best clients started exactly where you are now."
Step 2: Reframe the Conversation
Shift from defending your offering to exploring potential gaps in their current coverage.Example Response:
"I'm not here to replace your current provider. I'm here to ensure you have comprehensive protection that fully addresses your specific risk profile."
Step 3: Ask a Diagnostic Question
Questions are your secret weapon. They force the prospect to think critically about their current situation.Power Questions to Ask:
- "When was the last time you did a comprehensive review of your coverage?"
- "If you could improve one aspect of your current insurance protection, what would it be?"
- "What specific risks are most concerning to you right now?"
Real-World Example: Guardian Shield Insurance
When Guardian Shield Insurance encountered this objection with a mid-sized manufacturing client, their top sales rep didn't panic.
What Happened: The rep used the 3-step framework, uncovering that the client's current provider hadn't updated their policy in three years, leaving significant coverage gaps in emerging technology risks.
Key Takeaway: By asking strategic questions, they transformed a potential rejection into a $125,000 annual contract.
Industry-Specific Considerations for Insurance & Risk Management
Insurance sales require a nuanced approach. Unlike other industries, you're selling peace of mind, not just a product.
- Regulatory Complexity: Prospects fear compliance risks with switching providers
- Average Deal Size ($8,000): Requires more consultative, relationship-driven approach
- Typical Objection Triggers: Recent policy renewals, long-term relationships, perceived administrative hassle
5 Variations You Can Use Tomorrow
Variation 1: The Empathy Reframe "I appreciate your loyalty. Great relationships matter in insurance. I'm simply offering a complimentary second opinion."
Variation 2: The Social Proof Angle "We've helped 47 companies in your industry optimize their risk management without disrupting their existing relationships."
Variation 3: The Risk Reversal "What if I guarantee our review won't cost you anything, and we'll only recommend changes if we can demonstrably improve your protection?"
Variation 4: The Future-Pace "Let's imagine your business grows 30% in the next two years. Would your current coverage scale with you?"
Variation 5: The Direct Challenge "I respect your current provider. But are you 100% confident they're tracking all emerging risks in your industry?"
Common Follow-Up Objections (And How to Handle Them)
"We're happy with our current rates" → Focus on comprehensive protection, not just price. Show the potential hidden costs of inadequate coverage.
"It's too much work to switch" → Offer a white-glove transition process that removes all administrative burden from their team.
"Our current agent is a friend" → Emphasize that you're not replacing relationships, but complementing their existing protection.
The Bottom Line
Handling the "we're already working with someone else" objection isn't about aggressive tactics. It's about strategic curiosity, demonstrating value, and showing you understand their unique risk landscape.
Quick Win: Schedule a zero-obligation 15-minute coverage review. No pressure, pure value.
Want a Complete Script with 88 Pre-Built Objection Responses?
Stop scrambling for the right words in the moment. ScriptFly AI generates a complete, personalized sales script for your exact product and industry in under 5 minutes.
What You Get:
- ✅ 88 objection responses across all scenarios
- ✅ Multiple opening variations
- ✅ 7 proven closing techniques
- ✅ Email templates and follow-up sequences
- ✅ Unlimited revisions based on your real call feedback
$97 one-time payment. 14-day money-back guarantee.
Get Your Custom Sales Script →
Posted by ScriptFly AI Team
Ready to Never Get Stumped Again?
Get a complete sales script with 88+ objection responses tailored to your exact product and industry
Common Questions About This Objection
When is the best time to use this objection response?
Use this response immediately when you hear the objection. The key is to acknowledge their concern authentically before reframing it. Timing matters—respond too quickly and you seem dismissive, wait too long and you lose momentum.
What if this script doesn't work for my specific situation?
Every prospect is different. Use these scripts as frameworks, not word-for-word responses. Adapt the language to match your industry, product, and the prospect's communication style. The underlying psychology remains the same.
How do I practice these responses effectively?
Role-play with a colleague or record yourself. Focus on tone and delivery—confidence matters as much as the words. Practice until it feels natural, not scripted. The goal is to internalize the framework, not memorize lines.
Can I combine this with other objection handling techniques?
Absolutely. These responses work well with techniques like the "Feel, Felt, Found" method or the "Boomerang" technique. Layer multiple approaches for complex objections, but keep it conversational—never sound like you're running through a checklist.
How many times should I try before moving on?
If you've addressed the same objection 2-3 times using different angles and they're still not budging, it's likely not a real objection—it's a polite way of saying no. Know when to pivot or disqualify the prospect to focus on better opportunities.
More Insurance Objection Guides
How to Handle "I Need to Get Approval from My Team" in Insurance & Risk Management Sales
Expert framework for overcoming the "I Need to Get Approval from My Team" objection in Insurance & Risk Management. Proven scripts and industry-specific techniques.
How to Handle "Your Competitor is Cheaper" in Insurance & Risk Management Sales
Expert framework for overcoming the "Your Competitor is Cheaper" objection in Insurance & Risk Management. Proven scripts and industry-specific techniques.
How to Handle "Can You Provide References First?" in Insurance & Risk Management Sales
Expert framework for overcoming the "Can You Provide References First?" objection in Insurance & Risk Management. Proven scripts and industry-specific techniques.